18 Players The USMNT Should & Shouldn't Play In The Concacaf Nations League

When my wife and I got to our car in the parking garage this morning, I realized with great sadness I had left my cell phone — which I use to stream audiobooks on my morning commute — up in the condo, and since we were already a couple minutes late I decided not to waste several minutes retrieving it. 

My only natural recourse was to listen to National Public Radio, which for the most part discussed, during my 30-minute drive, the various Twitter attacks of our great nation’s politicians, but which in the end gave a little plug for a local journalism initiative in Austin. The small advertisement detailed a program that pairs college students at the University of Texas with professional journalists for a week to produce a piece.

Very cool!

I submit that the U.S. men’s national team must do the same thing for the upcoming Concacaf Nations League.

The U.S., in League A, just needs to top Canada and Cuba to reach the semifinals of the tournament — to be played in March 2020 — and that’s not much of a tall order. This isn’t the same accolade as the Gold Cup, and it shouldn’t be treated as such. What this should be about is letting the hungry youths loose. 

Therefore, I have assembled a few mentor/mentee groups for each unit of the field, as well as one U.S. veteran who I think we should leave at home to enjoy time with his friends and family, or something.

The Concacaf Nations League will be broadcast right here on FloFC, with one viewership note: the U.S. group games will be on television and not on FloFC. Should the U.S. make the semifinals and final, however, they would be on FloFC.

Shocking: fullbacks should be actual fullbacks, not center backs

Fullback mentor: DeAndre Yedlin

Fullback mentees: Reggie Cannon, Sergino Dest, Chris Gloster

Veteran to sit this one out: Tim Ream

Ream has served extremely well for the U.S., all things considered, but he’s not a left back, and he’s not the future at center back. Gregg Berhalter needs to dip into the U20 pool to get some juice at the fullback position. Both Dest (with Ajax) and Gloster (with Hannover 96) are inching closer and closer to the first team at their respective clubs, and both played extremely well at the U20 World Cup. Gloster is a true left back, while Dest mostly plays on the right but has occasionally played on the left as an opposite-footed fullback. 

We just have to face the facts — Ream can’t do stuff like this: 



And stuff like that is what you need nowadays. 

Reggie Cannon was a late add to the Gold Cup roster and ended up earning the starting role in the second half of the tournament; he was mostly excellent, and like the rest of the players in this fullback cadre he can blaze up and down the flank. If Berhalter is going to be overloading areas on the field, that’s the kind of player you want. 

Yedlin, of course, is still just 26, but he’s got a wealth of experience the other two lads don’t have. Should Yedlin remain healthy, the job is still his. Hopefully a one-two depth chart of Yedlin and Cannon would let Berhalter feel confident enough to put Tyler Adams in the midfield. 

Center backs are like Barolos: many need ample time

Center back mentor: John Brooks

Center back mentees: Matt Miazga, Chris Richards

Veteran to sit this one out: Omar Gonzalez

FloFC’s Zach Lowy recently wrote a great piece on the ascendant Richards, who’s attempting to crack the mammoth club that is Bayern Munich, but no matter what happens in his club future — immediately making the first team, getting loaned out to another Bundesliga outfit, transferring somewhere else — Richards has already proven what a talent he is in Poland. He covers a ton of ground, positions himself intelligently, attempts some ambitious balls out of the back, and has uncanny anticipation for his age.



Brooks has played well for Wolfsburg and really needs to be healthy, but if and when he does get fully fit I think Berhalter would do well to include him in the Nations League roster. He’s still just 26 years old, playing a position that is a little kinder on older players (Diego Godin is 33; Giorgio Chiellini is about to turn 35). The same point applies to Miazga. There’s been a little frustration around the 23-year-old, but he’s just 23! Give him time. His club career is up in the air at the moment, and he’s probably sick and tired of going out on loan. But if and when he finds a club at which to settle for a while, he’s still got a bright future. 

These three center backs — plus Aaron Long, as you’ll see on my full suggested 23-man roster below — could provide the U.S. stability at the position for years. Obviously Cameron Carter-Vickers is another one to watch, too. 

The midfielders need to get their sh** together

Midfield mentor: Weston McKennie

Midfield mentees: Alex Mendez, Paxton Pomykal

Veteran to sit this one out: Michael Bradley

Pulisic should not be wasting his energy in the midfield. 

For a U.S. side in desperate need of goal conversions as well as chances, the best player needs to be working in the final third with players around him making runs, rather than collecting the ball in the center of the pitch and being charged with orchestrating everything moving forward. 

Pomykal is a name that has been justifiably buzzing lately, but Mendez was integral for the U20 side that fared so well in Poland, too. The former is probably a bit more ready for first-team action, and he’d do wonders in a midfield alongside Adams and McKennie. That trio would offer Berhalter defensive solidity, technical ability, and some classic McKennie runs forward. Pomykal as the right midfielder would see some great link-up play with Pulisic, and the two would certainly enjoy a fruitful freedom on the right side of the field. 

The FC Dallas player is already doing this for his club:



That kind of creativity behind Pulisic would be gargantuan. But he also tracks aggressively on defense more than he’s given credit for; he can possess the ball without panicking, which is a needed trait and in scarce supply. But more than anything, it just feels like this is a midfield that would gel together. McKennie is only 20 years old, but like he proved in the Gold Cup, he’s probably going to take up Clint Dempsey’s mantle as the Intensity Sheriff for the squad. He’s already earned the captain’s armband, and putting a few talented guys around him would be extremely exciting. 

If only the attackers were as cool as Heath-Morgan-Rapinoe

Attacker mentor: Christian Pulisic

Attacker mentees: Sebastian Soto, Konrad de la Fuente, Timothy Weah

Veteran to sit this one out: Jozy Altidore

Look, I love Altidore, and right now he’s far and away the best striker the U.S. can field. But that should freak USMNT fans the hell out with the 2022 World Cup somewhat rapidly approaching. Altidore is 29 years old, and even if he keeps finding ways to mitigate the effects of age with increased creativity, the U.S. need an option for the future at No. 9, and they need creative wingers who can provide sustained, consistent support. 

What Altidore has done really well that, so far, nobody else has proven they can do, is provide quality hold-up play with enough vision and technical ability to play wingers into good attacking positions. Soto is young and completely unproven on the international or professional club level, but he showed glimpses of those two abilities in Poland with the U20s — as well as a nose for finishing chances and a penchant for quality runs. 



Weah, of course, has just completed a move away from PSG to Lille in what could be a picture-perfect scenario. Should his new French side sell attackers Nicolas Pepe and Rafael Leao, Weah will be given the opportunity to earn first-team minutes in the Champions League. De la Fuente is less of a proven product but, like Soto, in his limited action — he literally just turned 18 years old — he’s shown some snazzy stuff on the wings:



The U.S. needs sauce, as I’ve said before. I understand Berhalter not giving some of these kids a run during the Gold Cup; that’s a tournament in which you want to play the absolute best team you can play without taking too many risks. Hell, it nearly worked out for the U.S. The team plowed through the group games with ease — which was not a guarantee given the poor form before the tournament — and then out-played Mexico for 45 minutes before losing 1-0 in the final.

But this is the Nations League. You’ve got two games against Cuba and Canada and then a chance to win a trophy, but rather than making the trophy the No. 1 target I would look at this as an opportunity to cultivate some really talented young players and get them acclimated to the system as well as to the USMNT’s proven mainstays. 

Here’s what I’d do for a full 23-man roster:

Goalkeepers: Zack Steffen, Ethan Horvath, Brady Scott

Defenders: John Brooks, Chris Richards, Matt Miazga, Aaron Long, DeAndre Yedlin, Chris Gloster, Sergino Dest, Reggie Cannon

Midfielders: Tyler Adams, Weston McKennie, Duane Holmes, Paxton Pomykal, Alex Mendez

Attackers: Christian Pulisic, Sebastian Soto, Konrad de la Fuente, Timothy Weah, Josh Sargent, Tyler Boyd, Paul Arriola

And here’s how I’d play: 

Steffen

Yedlin / Richards / Brooks / Gloster

Pomykal / Adams / McKennie 

Pulisic / Sargent / Weah


The 4-3-3 morphs very easily into a 4-4-2 if needed, with Sargent and Weah the front two forwards; it could also slide into a 4-2-3-1 with Pomykal or Pulisic moving into the attacking midfielder position. 

This starting 11 combines youth and experience to a mild degree, but it’s aggressively pointed toward the future. It also creates some really juicy competition at a few positions. Without Altidore, Sargent and Soto would be battling for striker in camp and in the tournament. Holmes, Pomykal, and Mendez (they should start a law firm) scrap for the third midfield spot. If Weah falters, Boyd, Arriola, or de la Fuente lurk for that wing. And both positions in defense are rife with battles.

I can 100 percent guarantee you these are not the players Berhalter calls upon in September, though it’ll be interesting to see how many of these players are on, and I can also 100 percent guarantee you that this is not the best team the U.S. can assemble at this point in time — but in my mind, the goal of the Nations League should be to see which of these young studs can battle with the men. 

Don’t make this tournament the goal. Make the next tournament the goal.

Roma Defender Chris Smalling Has Been Stellar In Italy

As if he’d not made enough of an impression since joining AS Roma on loan from Manchester United in the summer, defender Chris Smalling really stood out as an exceptional talent on the week of his 30th birthday. 

Hofstra Coach Simon Riddiough Doesn't Need The Power 5 To Define Success

By Jerry Beach

Simon Riddiough, the head coach of the Hofstra women’s soccer team, spent about two minutes of a 21-minute interview Tuesday afternoon discussing why he’s content at the Long Island school and not planning to see if he can replicate his success with a higher-profile Power Five school that would offer the resources and opportunities to make a deep NCAA Tournament run that are generally lacking in the mid-major arena.

Carlo Ancelotti, Aurelio De Laurentiis & Napoli Are In Complete Chaos

It’s hard to believe that only as far back as April 22, 2018, Napoli beat Juventus 1-0 in Turin to move top of the table with only four games remaining. Maurizio Sarri — himself now in charge at Juve — had broken the club record points total in each of the previous two campaigns, and would do so again in 2017-18, but the Naples men ultimately finished second, albeit with yet another unseen total of 91 points.

Canada Has An Opportunity To Prove Their Standing On Friday Against USMNT

This is the moment of truth for Canada's men's national team. 

Concacaf Nations League Returns For Final Group State In November

After nearly a month of waiting for the Concacaf Nations League to kick back into gear, the tournament is finally back this week with the final two matchdays in group play. 

Seattle Sounders & Toronto FC Clash With The MLS Cup On The Line

Just over a week after the Seattle Sounders and Toronto FC went on the road and upset the favorites, MLS Cup 2019 is on the horizon as the 24th season in league history comes to a close. CenturyLink Field in Seattle will be the epicenter on Sunday at 3 PM when the two sides face off in the MLS Cup final for the third time in the past four years. 

Paulo Fonseca & The Unlikely Resurgence Of AS Roma In Serie A

It wasn’t supposed to be like this.

Potential USMNT Contributors From The Nations League Pre-Camp

November 15 could be a day of reckoning for Gregg Berhalter and the United States men's national team. After last month's 2-0 defeat to Canada — the first loss to their neighbors in 35 years — Berhalter needs a win in Orlando to help rectify the USA's position in the first-ever Concacaf Nations League. Anything other than a win would mean that Canada will advance to the semifinals, a shocking result for the U.S.

10 Things In Italy: Mario Balotelli, de Ligt Handballs & Conte's Inter

With the action in Italy heating up both on and off the field, it’s time to get you caught up with what’s been happening in the world of Serie A and, as always, “10 Things” is here to bring you right up to date.

Concaclusions, Ep. 9: Pulisic Strikes Again, Jiménez Haunts Arsenal

Another round of club play is in the books, and several of the region’s top players were in the headlines once again through clutch goals, quality performances, and even uncharacteristic errors.