MLS Fantasy Stats: Using Analytics To Build Out Your Lineup


You’ve just found out your star MLS Fantasy player isn’t in his real-life lineup for the week, and you’ve got 20 minutes before the next round of games start to pick the best replacement. You don’t have time for a full analysis of all the available players; you need to keep your breakdown to a minimum. You probably only have the ability to look at one or two key indicators to determine potential success.

I run the Twitter account @mlsfantasystats, offering weekly points predictions and advice to managers of MLS Fantasy (often abbreviated as FMLS). Often I am asked what indicators can be used to give a fantasy manager a good idea of how likely a particular player is to obtain a good score in a given week, especially if my predictions are not available for that round or if someone runs into the situation described above.

Earlier this year, I built a linear regression model which showed the correlation of the season averages for each relevant fantasy scoring category to the total points scored by a player in the next round.

In simpler terms, I used math to figure out how good individual stats such as assists, completed passes, or saves are at predicting future fantasy performance on their own.

Here are the results!

Here’s how to read this chart: Each of the numbers in the chart is called a correlation coefficient, often denoted by the letter r in statistics. It is a number between -1 and 1, with a strength of correlation indicated by the distance from 0. The farther away a stat’s correlation coefficient is from 0, the better that particular stat is at predicting the total points a player in that position will score in the next game. If the stat is close to 0, its effect on the total points a player scores is effectively random.

If you want a general sense of how easy it is to predict each position, look at the amount of green in each column: The greener it is, the easier it is to predict. Midfielders take the top prize for predictability here, with goalkeepers being the apparent loser. This shouldn’t come as a surprise, and it can be seen in the point distributions for each position.

Back to the original chart. Far and away the top indicator of fantasy performance overall is whether the player’s team is playing at home. I hope it should be obvious, but you'd better be highly confident in a player's performance in other areas if you plan on picking them on an away game. The deck is stacked against them, especially if they're defenders or goalkeepers. There are a few stats such as saves which are higher for the away team (3.6 saves/game versus 2.9), but most of the time they can’t make up for the massive disadvantage in the other stat areas for those on the road.

Now let’s break things down on a position-by-position level.


Number of Shots per 90 Minutes is the most predictive statistic for forward point production, followed closely by the omnipresent playing at home.

And it turns out when predicting forwards' points, it's just about as important that they don't get tackles as it is that they do score goals! Both stats are tied for third in correlation, but tackles are negatively correlated to forwards' FMLS point production, meaning the more tackles they get the less likely they are to get higher scores. Forwards are primarily tasked with scoring goals, and if they’re going around making tackles, they’re probably not scoring goals as often.

Out-of-position players can sometimes be a hidden gem for your team, but if a player is listed as a forward in MLS Fantasy but playing as a fullback or deeper-lying midfielder, best avoid them. They have all the downside of being a defender with a lack of ability to get attacking points with none of the upside of clean sheet chances.


Key Passes per 90 Minutes is the most predictive stat for midfielders. Note that since Assists is by definition a subset of Key Passes and is highly correlated to Key Passes (r = .640), the larger set of data points for Key Passes decreases the influence of randomness and makes it more likely to be a good predictor than Assists.

An interesting thing to note is that there are fairly strong negative correlations between the numbers of Clearances and Interceptions a midfielder has and their fantasy point production. It doesn't look good for defensive midfielders. What this doesn’t determine is whether those midfielders who have a higher amount of clearances and interceptions have what’s known as a “high floor,” meaning they have low variance and are almost guaranteed to get a few points each game. Perhaps that can be another topic for another article.

The biggest surprise is that Crosses per 90 Minutes has the second-highest correlation to FMLS Points! As it turns out, midfielders’ Crosses/90 is correlated not only with their Points but even more so with other variables such as Key Passes/90 (r = .777), Assists/90 (r = .505), and Big Chances Created/90 (r = -.368). This means it inherently contains a not-insignificant portion of the prediction ability of all these variables, adding up all that predictive power to become one of the best indicators for the position.


To put things succinctly, defenders playing at home is the highest correlation coefficient in the table, and that’s most of what you need to know.

Granted, how bad the player’s own defense is another decent indicator, along with the passing stats, but they pale in comparison to playing at home. Picking away defenders is a large risk.

Likely the most significant finding in this study is that the quality of the opposing offense (Opp xGF) is rather unimportant when choosing defenders and even less predictive than the opposing defense! Perhaps this is due to a change in style most teams have when playing away; there are many who blame at least some of home field advantage on a change to a more conservative playing style by teams when they are the visitors, making home field advantage somewhat of a self-fulfilling prophecy. The truth of defense wins silverware remains to be seen in soccer, but at least in the fantasy side of the sport, the ability of opponents to create scoring chances isn’t very useful in predicting defender performance.


Pick home goalkeepers. Period.

Honestly, every other stat in the study is garbage if used by itself to predict goalkeeper performance. With r = -0.01, even the number of saves a goalkeeper gets is essentially random when it comes to predicting FMLS points!

But if you’re going to use other stats besides home/away to choose your goalkeepers (and I strongly urge caution when doing so), note that the opponent’s defense (Opp xGA) is actually a better predictor of GK points than the keeper’s own team’s defense (Team xGA)! As it turns out, for goalkeepers, “the best offense” is a lack of opposition defense. My guess is that this phenomenon has something to do with clean sheet probabilities: the lower the quality of the opposing defense, the greater the chances of the goalkeeper’s team getting the lead and being able to sit back and defend better.

The variability inherent to goalkeeper scoring is why the keeperoo is a must-know strategy. According to Eric Thulin at MLS Fantasy Boss, the average keeperoo nets you 1.5 points for single-game-weeks just by using it because of how unpredictable keepers’ scores are! You basically get two shots at getting a good goalkeeper score, and with goalkeepers being the most variable position but the cheapest upgrade to a starter, I’d spend the extra few $$ on a second keeper to decrease the risk.

What We’ve Learned

If we were to boil this all down to a few takeaways, here’s what I’d recommend for you when you’re building your MLS Fantasy roster in the upcoming season.

Use the keeperoo. Goalkeepers are too unpredictable not to use this tactic if you have the budget. If given a choice between a keeperoo and a regular old switcheroo with outfield players, do the keeperoo if only for the inexpensive upgrade to a starter keeper from a bench-sitter.

Play home defenders on good defenses. Don’t pay much attention to their opponent.

Passes are the key to midfielders, particularly Key Passes and Crosses. That being said, midfielders who rely heavily on defensive actions for their points probably aren’t going to score as highly as their more offensive-minded counterparts such as attacking mids or wingers.

Get yourself forwards who shoot and shoot often. If you must look at their total goals so far, also look at their total tackles, because they’re about equal in their predictiveness.

And lastly, in case it wasn’t clear before, don’t use away players if you can help it. Just don’t.

One final piece of encouragement—if you can call it that. Even combining several of these variables into a multiple regression model (not shown here) still can only explain around 11 percent of the variance in players’ points. In other words, despite your best efforts, 8/9ths of your fantasy performance is either not yet understood or is just plain dumb luck. Happy lineup building!

Ryan Anderson is a data-driven insights evangelist currently working as a data analyst in Des Moines, IA. He moonlights as a certified soccer referee and provides player projections and advice for the MLS Fantasy community via his Twitter account.

D.C. United Can't Hold First-Half Lead, Lose 2-1 To NYCFC In Open Cup

D.C. United took a first-half lead in their Round of 16 U.S. Open Cup game against New York City FC at Audi Field on Wednesday night but couldn't make it count, falling 2-1 to exit the cup competition. Alexandru Mitrita scored in the 38th minute, and then Ismael Tajouri-Shradi scored the winner in the 41st minute, in the first-ever Open Cup game between the two sides.

D.C. United Eye U.S. Open Cup Quarterfinals With NYCFC Visit

Olsen Talks Open Cup And 2nd Half Of Season

A week after a dramatic late win over the Philadelphia Union, D.C. United host New York City FC at Audi Field on Wednesday night, hoping to advance to the quarterfinals of the U.S. Open Cup for the first time since 2013. The winner of the game on Wednesday night — the first matchup between the two Eastern Conference foes in the Open Cup — will go on to face either the New England Revolution or Orlando City in the quarterfinal stage.

USA Ease Past Guyana 4-0 To Open Up Gold Cup

The United States put up a scoreline that many predicted on Tuesday night, as Gregg Berhalter's side opened up their Gold Cup with a 4-0 win over Guyana at Allianz Field in St. Paul, Minnesota. Paul Arriola opened the scoring in the first half for the USA, and Tyler Boyd scored his first two goals for the team in his second cap after switching allegiances from New Zealand last month.

From Totti & Roma To Sarri & Juventus, Serie A's Top 6 Are In Chaos

Italy is nothing if not dramatic. 

US Men's National Team Open Gold Cup Against Debutants Guyana

After a tumultuous month, the USA finally begins their Gold Cup campaign this evening when they take on Guyana at Allianz Field, in St. Paul, Minnesota. Gregg Berhalter will be hoping to get his team back on track after ugly friendly losses to Jamaica and Venezuela earlier this month. The game kicks off at 10 PM ET and will be broadcast on FS1 and UniMas.

4 Positives In A Difficult Major League Soccer Debut From FC Cincinnati

What looked to be a picturesque maiden voyage for FC Cincinnati quickly ran aground. The Orange and Blue have produced a solitary victory in the 12 matches since their bright 2-1-1 start and find themselves looking up at the rest of the league with 11 points. As the Gold Cup break provides a brief opportunity to reboot and prepare for a grueling summer and fall, it’s time to have a look at the top storylines from the first half of Cincinnati’s inaugural season in Major League Soccer.

Maurizio Sarri May Not Be Pep Guardiola, But He Could Be Juventus' Answer

On Sunday the rumors finally became official: Maurizio Sarri is the new Juventus coach.

Christian Pulisic Holds Keys For USMNT Success At Gold Cup

After two recent friendly defeats, there are now more questions about Gregg Berhalter's USA side heading into the Gold Cup than there were a month ago. Injuries have robbed the manager of a couple of players in his squad, most notably Tyler Adams and John Brooks. Those two absences alone, though, don't account for worrying signs in the losses to Jamaica and Venezuela, games in which the U.S. failed to score a single goal.

5 Players To Watch At The 2019 Gold Cup Including Pizarro, Steffen, & More

The 2019 Concacaf Gold Cup is nearly upon us as 16 nations are set to square off for the title in a revamped format. Although Mexico and the United States are once again the favorites — only Canada have added a title — the 15th edition of the tournament features a number of intriguing storylines and Concacaf play is always full of surprises. 

Mexico Remain Gold Cup Favorites Despite Long List Of Absences

With recent friendly stumbles for the U.S., it seems like Mexico should be far and away favorites for the upcoming Gold Cup. But the most decorated Gold Cup team has a couple of issues of their own, even though the depth that Mexico possesses is unmatched in the Concacaf region.